Poach.rr / Comparisons
Comparison

Poach.rr vs EnergySage: Lead Source Comparison for Roofers

A plain comparison of Poach.rr and EnergySage for roofers: how each describes its lead source, and what to ask any vendor before you buy.

By the Poach.rr data team · October 21, 2026

What EnergySage says about itself

Quoted from https://www.energysage.com/, retrieved October 21, 2026.

“connecting homeowners with pre-screened, certified installers”
“Compare quotes, explore financing options, and learn how much you can save with solar.”
“a free, unbiased Energy Advisor by your side”
“make clean home energy solutions affordable and accessible to all”
“Solar & HVAC installers”

The short version

The two sources start from different places. Poach.rr is a marketplace of roofing, solar and HVAC prospects built from public building-permit records. On its home page, EnergySage describes its model as “connecting homeowners with pre-screened, certified installers.” One starts from the permit history of a property. The other, by its own wording, starts from a homeowner comparing quotes. This page sets out what each says about itself so you can judge which fits the way you sell.

How Poach.rr works

Everything below comes from how Poach.rr describes itself, and nothing more.

  • Prospects are built from public building-permit records, covering roofing, solar and HVAC.
  • HVAC prospects are homes whose last HVAC permit on record is 12 or more years old, or homes with no HVAC permit since they were built. They are scored from permit history.
  • You pick a state and county, filter by permit age, and buy a prospect exclusively or shared with other contractors.
  • Homeowner contact details are looked up on demand after purchase. Numbers flagged on do-not-call lists are marked.
  • Data is swept daily from public permit portals.
  • New accounts get free prospects to try the marketplace, no card required.

One limit matters here. Coverage depends on which jurisdictions publish permits. Any count you see is permits in our dataset, not every permit in a county. If your service area is served by a portal that publishes late or not at all, you will see less than actually exists.

How the other site describes itself

We read the home page of the other site and use only its own wording. We have not tested the service, and we do not describe how it works beyond what the page says.

The page says homeowners can “Compare quotes, explore financing options, and learn how much you can save with solar.” That is a homeowner-facing pitch. A roofer reading it should ask what it means for an installer on the receiving end.

It also promises homeowners “a free, unbiased Energy Advisor by your side.” That tells you the site puts an advisor between the homeowner and the installer. We cannot see from the page how that affects the installer.

Its stated mission is to “make clean home energy solutions affordable and accessible to all.” That is a homeowner-side goal. The page does not say how a roofing contractor would use the marketplace.

The navigation does list an installer entry point. The footer includes “Solar & HVAC installers” under a “Work with us” heading. We did not follow it, so we cannot say what it offers roofers.

Side by side

QuestionPoach.rrSolar quote marketplace, in its own words
Where does the prospect come from?Public building-permit records“connecting homeowners with pre-screened, certified installers”
Who do you choose?A state, a county and a permit-age filterNot stated on the page we read
Exclusive or shared?You choose when you buyNot stated on the page we read
Contact detailsLooked up on demand after purchase, do-not-call numbers markedNot stated on the page we read
Trade focusRoofing, solar and HVAC“Solar & HVAC installers” appears as a link label

Which fits a roofer

If you want to choose a county and work from permit age, Poach.rr is built for that. You can see how old a property’s last permit is before you buy, and you decide whether to buy exclusively or shared. The tradeoff is that a permit record shows a home’s history. It does not show that a homeowner is looking to hire anyone.

If you want inbound requests from homeowners who are already shopping, a quote marketplace is a different model. The wording “Compare quotes, explore financing options, and learn how much you can save with solar” suggests that setting. Whether the volume and fit work for a roofing business is something the home page does not answer, so ask before you commit.

What to ask any lead vendor

These questions work for any source, including ours.

  1. Where does each lead come from? Ask for the original source, such as a permit record, a form or a call.
  2. Is it exclusive or shared? Ask how many other contractors can receive the same lead.
  3. How fresh is the data? Ask how often it updates and how late filings are handled.
  4. What is the coverage in my area? Ask which counties and jurisdictions are actually included, and which are missing.
  5. How is contact information obtained? Ask when it is looked up, and whether do-not-call numbers are marked.
  6. Can I try it first? Ask what a trial includes and whether a card is needed.
  7. What happens with a bad lead? Ask for the replacement or refund process in writing.

Limits of this comparison

We describe the other site only through the quoted wording above, taken from its home page. Marketing copy shows how a company positions itself, not how it performs for installers. Run a small test with any source before you spend serious budget on it, and track what you close.

Frequently asked questions

What is Poach.rr?

Poach.rr is a marketplace of roofing, solar and HVAC prospects built from public building-permit records. Coverage depends on which jurisdictions publish permits.

How does Poach.rr identify HVAC prospects?

HVAC prospects are homes whose last HVAC permit on record is 12 or more years old, or with no HVAC permit since the home was built. They are scored from permit history.

Can I buy a prospect exclusively?

Yes. You pick a state and county, filter by permit age, and buy a prospect exclusively or shared with other contractors.

Can I try Poach.rr before paying?

New accounts get free prospects to try the marketplace, and no card is required.

What does EnergySage say it does?

Its home page describes the service as “connecting homeowners with pre-screened, certified installers.” The page does not explain how roofers would use it.

Sources

Statements about EnergySage are quoted from its public website as retrieved on the date shown above; check their site for current terms. Statements about Poach.rr describe the product as of October 21, 2026. This page is refreshed monthly.