Poach.rr / Comparisons
Comparison

Poach.rr vs Shovels: Choosing a Roofing Lead Source

Poach.rr vs Shovels: how a permit-based prospect marketplace differs from a permit data platform, plus questions to ask any lead vendor.

By the Poach.rr data team · October 20, 2026

What Shovels says about itself

Quoted from https://www.shovels.ai/, retrieved October 20, 2026.

“The prediction engine for the built world”
“Gathered directly from every jurisdiction we cover, not licensed and not brokered”
“Explore, filter, and export permit, contractor, and decision data in our self-serve web app”
“Build construction intelligence into your product, CRM, or internal tools with our REST API”
“Contractor profiles with licenses, work history, and contact details”
“Get the full dataset as parquet files or table shares in Snowflake, Databricks, or BigQuery”

The short version

Poach.rr is a marketplace of roofing, solar and HVAC prospects built from public building-permit records. Shovels calls itself “The prediction engine for the built world”. That wording points to a data product rather than a contractor lead marketplace, so the two may suit different jobs. This page uses only Poach.rr's own facts and the competitor's homepage text, fetched on 2026-10-20. We have not tested the competitor's product.

What Poach.rr is

Poach.rr turns permit history into prospects you can buy. Here is how it works:

  • You pick a state and county.
  • You filter by permit age.
  • You buy a prospect exclusively, or shared with other contractors.

For HVAC, a prospect is a home whose last HVAC permit on record is 12 or more years old, or a home with no HVAC permit since it was built. Each is scored from permit history. The prospects come from recorded permits in our dataset, which is swept daily from public permit portals.

How the competitor describes itself

On its homepage, Shovels says its data is “Gathered directly from every jurisdiction we cover, not licensed and not brokered”. That is a claim about sourcing, and the page gives no detail on how a roofer would turn that data into a job list.

For delivery, Shovels describes a web app where you can “Explore, filter, and export permit, contractor, and decision data in our self-serve web app”. It also pitches developers: “Build construction intelligence into your product, CRM, or internal tools with our REST API”. Larger buyers get another route, since Shovels offers to let you “Get the full dataset as parquet files or table shares in Snowflake, Databricks, or BigQuery”.

Those descriptions fit a team that wants to query data, export it, or build on it. A marketplace like Poach.rr fits a contractor who wants to pick a county, filter by permit age and buy prospects without building anything.

Contact details and do-not-call flags

With Poach.rr, homeowner contact details are looked up on demand after purchase. Numbers flagged on do-not-call lists are marked, so you can see them before you dial.

Shovels lists “Contractor profiles with licenses, work history, and contact details” as one of its datasets. That describes contractor profiles. The homepage text does not say whether homeowner contact details or do-not-call flags are part of it, so ask if that matters to you.

Coverage

Coverage in Poach.rr depends on which jurisdictions publish permits. If a county's portal does not publish, there is nothing to sweep. Check your own counties before you rely on any permit-based source.

The competitor's homepage points to a coverage dashboard for this, and the same check applies to it. The quote “Gathered directly from every jurisdiction we cover” also implies that coverage is limited to the jurisdictions it lists.

Which one fits which buyer

  • You want prospects to call this week: a marketplace is built for that. Poach.rr lets you filter by permit age and choose exclusive or shared.
  • You want to build your own tools or analysis: a platform that offers an API or warehouse delivery, like the one in “Build construction intelligence into your product, CRM, or internal tools with our REST API”, is closer to that need.
  • You want to test before committing: new Poach.rr accounts get free prospects to try the marketplace, no card required.

What to ask any lead vendor

These questions work for Poach.rr, for the competitor, and for anyone else:

  1. Where does each record come from, and how often is it refreshed?
  2. Which of my counties are covered, and which are not?
  3. Is the record a prospect I can act on, or raw data I must process?
  4. Is the lead exclusive to me, or shared with other contractors?
  5. When do I get homeowner contact details, and are do-not-call numbers marked?
  6. Can I try it on my own market before paying?
  7. How do I export what I buy, and what does the vendor do with my searches?

Ask for answers in writing. Then test a small batch in one county and compare the permit history against what you know about those homes.

Bottom line

Shovels presents itself as “The prediction engine for the built world”, with delivery through an app, an API and bulk files. Poach.rr is narrower: roofing, solar and HVAC prospects from recorded permits, bought by county. If you want a list to work, start with the marketplace. If you want to build your own data pipeline, read the platform's documentation. Either way, check coverage in your own counties first.

Frequently asked questions

Is Poach.rr a data platform or a lead marketplace?

Poach.rr is a marketplace of roofing, solar and HVAC prospects built from public building-permit records. You pick a state and county, filter by permit age, and buy a prospect exclusively or shared.

How does Poach.rr define an HVAC prospect?

An HVAC prospect is a home whose last HVAC permit on record is 12 or more years old, or one with no HVAC permit since the home was built. Each is scored from permit history.

How does Shovels say it delivers its data?

Its homepage says you can “Explore, filter, and export permit, contractor, and decision data in our self-serve web app”. It also lists an API and bulk dataset delivery.

Can I try Poach.rr before paying?

Yes. New accounts get free prospects to try the marketplace, and no card is required.

Does Poach.rr cover every county?

No. Data is swept daily from public permit portals, and coverage depends on which jurisdictions publish permits. Check your own counties first.

Sources

Statements about Shovels are quoted from its public website as retrieved on the date shown above; check their site for current terms. Statements about Poach.rr describe the product as of October 20, 2026. This page is refreshed monthly.